Only Murders: Can London Renew More Than the Show’s Address?

This article contains spoilers for the first five seasons.

The Arconia must have the hardest apartments to sell in New York. After so many murders, secret passageways, suspicious residents and even a casino, that prestigious address seems to have become a prison with an open-door policy. Only Murders in the Building recognized the absurdity and began making fun of it. But the joke also exposes a challenge: how do you keep finding bodies inside the same building without exhausting the story?

I love this show. For me, it is one of the best comedies of recent years, with a narrative intelligence that its apparent lightness sometimes disguises. That is precisely why the arrival of season six in December raises expectations beyond discovering the next killer. Charles, Oliver and Mabel are heading to London. The question is whether a change of city will also move their lives forward.

When the building became a leading character

When the series premiered in 2021, its premise seemed perfectly contained: three neighbors who barely knew one another, and did not necessarily tolerate one another, discovered a shared passion for a true-crime podcast. A murder in their building brought them together and provided material for an investigation and a podcast of their own. It combined two contemporary obsessions with a classic mystery structure.

Steve Martin and Martin Short already had an extraordinary comedy partnership. Selena Gomez brought another generation, another rhythm and a deadpan delivery that struck a balance between Charles-Haden Savage’s peculiarities and Oliver Putnam’s theatrical excess. Mabel Mora also had a personal connection to the first victim, Tim Kono, her childhood friend, which kept the investigation from being merely a diversion for three nosy neighbors.

The unlikely trio worked immediately. But the Arconia became a star too: its corridors, apartments, employees and hierarchies formed a small universe. It was easy to imagine that setting naturally sustaining two or three seasons. I do not know whether that was the creators’ original plan, but the show’s longevity turned the restriction in its title into an increasingly entertaining creative problem — and an increasingly difficult one to work around.

Along came secret passageways, residents of the West Tower, hidden businesses and a real-estate battle that, in season five, almost offers a practical conclusion to all this chaos. After so many crimes, the threat to the building’s future makes a peculiar kind of sense. Who would still pay a fortune to live there?

A comedy that knows how to tell stories

Reducing Only Murders to a good idea stretched too far would be unfair. The series experiments with storytelling, and some of its finest moments have come from that willingness.

The almost entirely dialogue-free episode “The Boy from 6B,” in season one, builds its story around Theo’s perspective as a deaf character, turning listening — the very foundation of a podcast — into a question of point of view. It is a formal choice that contributes to both the mystery and the emotional experience.

Season three remains my favorite. The musical, the Broadway backstage world, the superstitions, the performers’ egos and the relationship between talent and recognition made for a delicious combination. Paul Rudd and, especially, Meryl Streep entered a story that had room and purpose for them. Theater gave the series an entire world to explore while placing Oliver at the center of something that truly mattered to him.

Season four, which I consider slightly weaker, still found ingenious ways to play with cinema. The Hollywood excursion, the episodes’ different stylistic approaches and the interplay between characters and the actors portraying them revealed a writing team interested in form. Eugene Levy, Zach Galifianakis and Eva Longoria as the trio’s movie counterparts were a joke about the manufacturing of entertainment itself.

For anyone who enjoys mysteries, theater or cinema, or makes a living telling stories, there is considerable pleasure in that construction. Even when I managed to predict the killers’ identities, I still wanted to follow the journey. The solution was never the only reason to watch.

When everyone wants to join in

Success, however, brought another challenge. Only Murders became a place where seemingly everyone wanted to appear. And I completely understand: who would turn down the chance to play alongside Steve Martin, Martin Short and Selena Gomez?

The problem is that the parade of guest stars began competing with the show itself. Melissa McCarthy is hilarious as Charles’s sister. Christoph Waltz finds the humor in his character. Renée Zellweger has the presence to sustain the absurdity. But, taken together, these appearances create a parallel expectation: who is showing up now, who comes next, which star will appear after that?

In the Hollywood season, the trio was accompanied by another trio of celebrities. The idea made sense within the story, but it also illustrated the expansion of a production that no longer needed to prove its ability to attract anyone. Sometimes, I miss having a little more room for the three people who brought us there.

I also think its recognition at the major comedy awards has fallen short of what the series deserves. Competition in a category that accommodates such different productions does not always favor a comedy openly committed to making us laugh. There have been important wins: in 2025, Martin Short won the SAG Award for male actor in a comedy series, and the ensemble was honored too. Still, the absence of an Emmy for his portrayal of Oliver continues to bother me. That year, the award went to Seth Rogen for The Studio.

What has changed for Charles, Oliver and Mabel?

My biggest question, as we approach season six, concerns the protagonists. They have been through a great deal. But how much have their lives actually changed?

Charles remains the lonely former television star, trapped in his habits, insecurities and the ego of someone who once enjoyed greater recognition. His friendship with Oliver and Mabel is a fundamental transformation, of course. There have also been relationships, losses and family revelations. Even so, the series frequently returns him to the same emotional starting point, as though every change must be contained to preserve the next joke.

Oliver has moved forward the most. His marriage to Loretta, Meryl Streep’s character, brought a tangible change. He remains excessive, vain and hilarious, but his life has taken on a different shape. The childhood memories explored in season five also added something to the man behind the perpetual performance.

Mabel is the one whose story feels most suspended to me. She has had romances, explored professional possibilities and changed her relationship with the building, yet she still seems to be living provisionally within her own life. The issue is not whether she dates men or women, nor whether she needs a conventional destination. It is that her desires, projects and choices do not always receive enough continuity to build a trajectory beyond the next investigation.

Does a comedy need to change its characters? Not always. Repetition is part of the pleasure of returning to them. But after five seasons, there is a difference between recognizing a personality and anticipating every move the writers will allow that person to make.

London, Agatha Christie and a conveniently placed gate

The move to London rests on a tenuous connection that the series itself treats as a joke. At the end of season five, Cinda Canning, the podcaster played by Tina Fey who inspired the trio, arrives dying outside the Arconia. Even the body’s position in relation to the gate becomes a subject of debate: some connection to the “building” in the title must be preserved.

It is a thin thread, but it is also a choice with potential. The new victim brings the story back to the woman whose work first brought the protagonists together. There is something of a return to the beginning in this journey, despite the change of country.

Season six premieres on December 8 and brings together names including Olivia Colman, David Tennant, Nicola Coughlan and Martin Freeman, alongside the returning Meryl Streep. The cast is irresistible. It also makes that question of balance even more important: how much room will remain for Charles, Oliver and Mabel?

An affinity with Agatha Christie feels natural for a series that enjoys eccentric suspects, confined settings and clues hidden in plain sight. And the calendar adds a delicious coincidence: December 2026 marks one hundred years since the writer’s disappearance in December 1926. This year also marks the centenary of The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. That does not confirm a tribute within the storyline, but it provides an especially appealing context for the trip.

There is still no official confirmation of a seventh season in the information available so far. For now, London is the next stop, and I am happy to close out the year with one of my favorite shows.

I want to laugh at Charles’s habits, Oliver’s flights of fancy and Mabel’s dry responses. I want to try to identify the killer and be surprised by the storytelling. But I would also like them, among so many distinguished guests, to find time to discover what they want to do with their own lives. Leaving the Arconia could be a very good start.


Descubra mais sobre

Assine para receber nossas notícias mais recentes por e-mail.

Deixe um comentário