Contains spoilers for “Liberty Unleashed.”
The second season of All’s Fair didn’t have a high bar to clear for story and drama. Yet it set aside some of what the first season had laid out and revisited familiar territory, once again teasing fans with a few very particular references.
Starting with the aftermath of last week’s attack.
After a Thanksgiving dinner with two gunshots, a secret daughter, and an inheritance at stake, the person who finally gets under Allura Grant’s skin works in human resources. And Liberty Ronson is the one who opens the door for her. The fifth episode of All’s Fair finally gives Naomi Watts a fight of her own. There’s a divorce involving red paint, Cauã Reymond saying goodbye with a hug that goes on the HR record, and, for those who’ve been waiting, a night in a hotel for Liberty and Carr.
Dina Hears Everything, and Carr Has the Texts
Dina is still in a coma, but the episode lets us hear her thoughts. Film buffs and Glenn Close fans will recognize the device Ryan Murphy borrows from 1990s Reversal of Fortune. Close played wealthy heiress Sunny von Bülow, who narrates the film from a coma.
When Liberty visits, she admits she feels left out when Allura and Emerald arrange to come to the hospital without inviting her. It’s a small grievance in light of everything that happened at dinner, but it says a lot about Liberty’s place in the group. She’s a partner at the firm and still wonders why she has to wait for her friends to remember to include her. It was a recurring complaint last season, too, and got just as much attention then. Some things never change.
Carr overhears part of the conversation and finds the quickest way to make things worse, just as she has before. This time, she grabs Dina’s phone and shows Liberty texts in which Dina and Allura bad-mouth her. (She also gets in a joke about Kim’s skin tone, a longtime topic of debate among fans.)
Carr suggests Liberty take it up with HR. There’s just one detail. The firm has never had an HR department. By this point, I already wanted to know what Dina would say if she could interrupt the conversation happening in her own hospital room. Later, when Brody visits and tells her he loves her, it’s through her thoughts that we learn she feels the same way. For the record, I still don’t trust him.
The Bride, the Red Paint, and Cody’s Lawyer
Crystal wants a divorce from Cody. His sister threw red paint on her at their wedding, and what Crystal holds against her husband is that he never stood up for her. Allura looks at a marriage that lasted only 17 months and warns her that long-term spousal support will be hard to get. Liberty promises to pursue a better deal. It’s easy to see why she identifies so quickly with a client who’s tired of waiting for someone to stand up for her. The trouble is that Liberty makes the promise before she knows what she has to work with. And the two lawyers argue in front of others.
At the negotiation, Cody’s lawyer, Jay Wilson (Nyle DiMarco), asks for an annulment. His client says the marriage was never consummated. Jay, who is deaf and attends the meeting with his interpreter, George, also brings up Crystal’s diagnosis of post-traumatic stress disorder following the incident at the wedding. Liberty’s position gets harder to defend, but she comes away impressed by Jay. He says he admires Dina, gives Liberty his card, and offers to help with the firm’s caseload.
By now, we can agree with Liberty that it’s a mystery where she fits into Allura and Emerald’s view of the world. We can also agree with the two of them that Liberty is insecure and can be spectacularly clueless. Still, Liberty is the one who takes the idea further and suggests hiring Jay. Emerald reminds her that having an all-female legal team has always been part of the firm’s identity. Now there’s a debate that deserved more time than the show gave the divorce itself.
Reese Arrives, and Raul’s Hug Becomes an HR Matter
Acting on Dina’s behalf, Carr proposes creating an HR department. Allura, who really does seem oblivious to the people around her, is vehemently opposed, and on this one I’m with her. She’s outvoted. Of course Liberty backs Carr, and once Emerald votes in favor, the partners hire Reese.
The first thing HR does is hear from the younger lawyers. Soon there are complaints about Allura’s visible underwear and Emerald’s plunging necklines, echoing what plenty of fans have been saying on social media. Kim, sorry, Allura, makes the case that dressing sexually can be an expression of feminist empowerment, an argument plenty of women make. She comes up against a set of decidedly conservative objections that are hard to dismiss.
Reese also proposes counseling for employees who returned to work after a shooting in the office. Of all the issues she raises, that’s the one the partners should already have discussed on their own. It’s classic HR: dangerous in the way HR can be, and essential in the way HR can be.
Raul (Cauã Reymond) tells Allura that with Marcus behind bars, she can feel safe again. They say goodbye, but she calls him back for a hug in a nod to The Bodyguard. Reese sees Raul’s hand on Allura’s derrière and logs the contact as a possible violation. After spending so much of last week’s episode waiting for Raul to come out of the bathroom, I confess I never imagined his next big problem would be a hug.
Carr Tells Liberty Why She Got Close to Her
The proposal to hire Jay turns the conversation between the partners downright ugly. Allura and Emerald say Liberty’s feelings for Carr are clouding her judgment. Neither seems to consider her own part in the fight or, more importantly, acknowledge that Liberty has raised this before and has a point. Liberty tells them Carr has been a friend to her and walks out.
Later, she meets Carr at a hotel. They flirt and spend the night together. Once they’re alone, Carr admits she initially got close to Liberty to gain influence at the firm. She also says that by now, she genuinely likes her. Liberty would rather keep the relationship a secret. Carr being Carr, there may well be some truth in what she says. I’d still keep an eye on the plan she just admitted to.
It’s the pair’s best scene because Sarah Paulson can let Carr admit to something ugly without asking us to forget what she’s capable of. And Naomi Watts leaves us with a question. How much of Liberty’s relief comes from getting to choose Carr, and how much comes from finally feeling that someone has chosen her?
Emerald makes the last move. She goes to Reese and files a formal complaint against Liberty. The HR department Liberty helped create already has one of the partners in its sights. And Carr, who put the idea on the table, now shares a secret with Liberty that the other two already suspect.
Descubra mais sobre
Assine para receber nossas notícias mais recentes por e-mail.
