“I do.” Those are the final words of the first teaser for Season 2 of Presumed Innocent, and they work just as well at the altar as they do on the witness stand. Over the course of 50 seconds, Rachel Brosnahan, Matthew Rhys, Courtney B. Vance, and Fiona Shaw raise their right hands as we hear the familiar oath. The music swells until it almost drowns out the question, and Jack Reynor is the one who finally answers. I like the double meaning, especially since the defence attorney and the prosecutor trying to pick her arguments apart will have to go home together when court adjourns.
When the series premiered in June 2024, there were at least three good reasons to imagine a franchise built around Rusty Sabich. The first was Scott Turow’s 1987 bestseller. The second was Harrison Ford in the 1990 film. For those of us who first met Rusty at the movies, he’s still a presence. And the third was that Turow had already returned to those characters in his 2010 novel Innocent. If you wanted to know what happened to that family after the trial, there was a whole book waiting for you.


Apple did exactly what I’m always complaining about. It took the title, the characters and the premise that drew us in, then decided to “update” the story. It changed who defends Rusty, the circumstances of the crime and, most importantly, who killed Carolyn. That last choice bothers me most because it changes what Rusty and Barbara’s marriage means. When they look at each other after the trial, the secret between them is an entirely different one. So when Apple renewed the series before the finale had even aired, I was curious. How do you adapt Turow’s sequel after changing the very thing that family would have to live with for the next twenty years?
Both David E. Kelley and Turow offered an explanation. Kelley told TheWrap he’d written the first season as a limited series and felt he’d finished telling the story of Jake Gyllenhaal’s Rusty. Its success earned it a renewal, but Kelley thought staying with the same characters would mean repeating himself. Turow added a detail that matters. Innocent takes place some twenty years later and gives Tommy Molto a central role. Peter Sarsgaard, who played him, had made it clear from the start that he didn’t do sequels. The third book, Presumed Guilty, published in 2025, jumps even further ahead. By the time Rusty agrees to defend his fiancée’s son against a murder charge, 35 years have passed since the original case. There was plenty of material. What Kelley wanted to keep exploring was what happens when a murder exposes the secrets in a marriage. For that, he went looking for another couple in another book.
That book is Dissection of a Murder, Jo Murray’s debut novel. Rachel Brosnahan plays Lelia Reynolds, an up-and-coming attorney who takes on a murder case and finds her own husband, played by Matthew Rhys, leading the prosecution. I still find it curious that we need to call this story Presumed Innocent, but I’ll admit I have higher hopes for this season than I did for the first. Kelley practised law before he started writing for television and went on to create The Practice, Ally McBeal and Boston Legal. Just think of the difference between Bobby Donnell in court and Alan Shore delivering a closing argument, and you’ll understand why I want to hear Kelley write an argument for two lawyers who know each other a little too well. Who’ll be the first to realise the other is hiding something? And will they save the question for dinner?


And then there’s Matthew Rhys. Those of us who first knew him as lawyer Kevin Walker on Brothers & Sisters have already seen him return to court as Perry Mason, with a different posture, a different voice, a different way of occupying a room. In between, he played a spy on The Americans who also knew a thing or two about keeping secrets in a marriage. More recently, he went from the menacing Niles Jarvis in The Beast in Me to the mayor trying to lure tourists to a cursed island in Widow’s Bay. I find it remarkable that after watching him play two lawyers, I’m still curious to see what he’ll do with a third. Especially with Rachel Brosnahan on the other side of the courtroom.
Season 2 of Presumed Innocent premieres on Apple TV on February 19, 2027, with two episodes. The remaining six arrive on Fridays through April 2.
Descubra mais sobre
Assine para receber nossas notícias mais recentes por e-mail.
