Contains spoilers for the first-season finale of War.
The first season of War has come to an end on HBO Max with an irony that, while interesting, is not enough to compensate for some of the writing problems accumulated over eight episodes. After a multimillion-dollar dispute, espionage, betrayals, manipulation, and dirty tricks, the divorce that drove the entire story ends practically with a conversation. Carla Duval (Sienna Miller) and Morgan Henderson (Dominic West) reach an agreement, abandon their legal battle, and seem to discover that they could have settled their differences without the lawyers they hired to defend them. But did things really have to go that far for them to realize it?
Created by George Kay, War begins with an excellent premise: exposing the behind-the-scenes dealings of a divorce between two extremely wealthy and famous people, handled by equally powerful law firms whose lawyers are willing to cross practically any line to win. In principle, the concept offered an opportunity to explore not only legal strategies but, above all, the transformation of a romantic relationship into a destructive conflict. The series, however, seems more interested in the competition between the lawyers than in the marriage falling apart. And that choice ultimately undermines the impact of its many twists.
The Dirty Work of Divorce Lawyers
Anyone who has been through a divorce knows that separation is rarely just about financial or legal matters. Even when both parties have made a mature decision to end the relationship, there are resentments, frustrations, insecurities, and a shared history that does not simply disappear with the signing of a document. What should be a negotiation can quickly become a battle to determine who was right, who suffered more, who sacrificed more, and who deserves to emerge victorious.
It is precisely at this moment of emotional vulnerability that lawyers enter the picture. Many are excellent mediators who understand that reaching an agreement may be in everyone’s best interest. Others take a combative approach, encouraging or amplifying conflicts that might otherwise have been resolved more peacefully. Depending on the agreement and the applicable professional rules, fee arrangements may also create financial incentives tied to the outcome of a dispute. This does not mean that every lawyer operates this way, but it would be naive to assume that professional conduct is always entirely detached from the economic interests involved.
There is another particularly delicate aspect: people who are hurting do not always want reconciliation. They want their suffering acknowledged; they want compensation, and sometimes they want the other person to suffer as well. Pettiness can temporarily take hold of even the most reasonable individuals. Minor material issues acquire disproportionate emotional significance, and what began as the end of a relationship can turn two people who once loved each other into enemies.

War had all the material it needed to explore this. Instead, it chooses to turn the divorce into a competition between two major law firms, Cathcarts and Taylor & Byrne, whose professionals are determined to prove who is smarter, more powerful, and more ruthless. They resort to espionage, witness manipulation, withholding information, and strategies designed not merely to protect their clients’ interests but to destroy their opponents’ credibility. The result is an entertaining, occasionally gripping legal thriller that neglects the very human conflict that should have sustained the narrative.
Carla Duval: A Movie Star Who Never Feels Like One
One of the series’ biggest problems lies in the construction of Carla Duval. We are repeatedly told that she is an internationally famous movie actress, a celebrity whose professional life and public image should be directly affected by the scandal surrounding her divorce. But where is this major star?
Sienna Miller certainly has the presence and experience to portray a wealthy, emotionally vulnerable woman. The problem is that Carla never feels like an internationally renowned actress. She does not behave like someone accustomed to dealing with the press, managing reputational crises, negotiating multimillion-dollar contracts, or controlling her public image. Her profession seems to exist solely to justify her wealth, glamour, and the media’s interest in her separation.
The series tells us who Carla is but rarely allows us to experience that identity. We know almost nothing about her relationship with cinema, her career, her ambitions, or the professional world that should be an integral part of her life. When we finally discover, in the last episode, that her influence and personal connections were instrumental in the growth of Morgan’s company, the revelation functions more as a legal argument than as character development. It was far too important a detail to introduce so late.
Dominic West, meanwhile, seems once again perfectly comfortable playing a privileged, arrogant, morally ambiguous man. The actor has portrayed so many variations of this character that even his Prince Charles in The Crown carried something of the same discomfort with responsibility and personal desire. In War, Morgan is yet another powerful, unfaithful man, accustomed to getting what he wants and willing to turn his marriage into a power struggle.
But there is one question the series never satisfactorily answers: how did these two people end up getting divorced?
We know about the betrayals, resentments, and financial disputes. What we do not know is how Carla and Morgan fell in love, what they built together, when they began drifting apart, or what still existed between them. A ten-year marriage cannot be reduced to the circumstances that led to its dissolution. Without understanding that history, it becomes difficult to appreciate the depth of their conflict and, more importantly, to believe in the emotional reconciliation suggested by the final episode.
Johnny Warren: What Did He Actually Want?
If Carla and Morgan are underdeveloped, Johnny Warren (Archie Renaux) may be the most confusing character of the entire season. Introduced as an ambitious young lawyer from a social background far removed from the legal elite, he returns to London after a mysterious stint in New York. We know he worked at a prestigious firm and that something damaged his professional trajectory, but the series never explains exactly what happened.
Johnny seems determined to secure a place among the legal profession’s most successful figures. To achieve that, he agrees to act as an informant, infiltrating the rival firm and passing along privileged information. He manipulates colleagues, deceives his superiors, compromises personal relationships, and jeopardizes his own career. All in the name of an ambition that never becomes sufficiently clear.
What does Johnny want? Money? Prestige? Power? Recognition? To belong to an elite that has always treated him as an outsider?
There are hints that his need for professional advancement may be connected to an attempt to overcome feelings of inadequacy. That could have been an interesting motivation, particularly because his social background distinguishes him from characters who move effortlessly through the series’ luxurious environments. But the idea is never explored convincingly.
What is particularly curious is that Johnny repeatedly puts at risk precisely what he is fighting to achieve. He obtains a professional opportunity and immediately begins behaving in ways that could destroy it. When his lies are exposed, he tries to recover his lost position through further manipulation. And in the finale, after helping resolve the conflict between Carla and Morgan, he returns to Serena’s office asking for another chance.
His behavior could be interpreted as self-sabotage, but we would need to know much more about his history to support that reading. Otherwise, Johnny functions less as a complex character and more as a plot device, someone who does whatever the narrative requires to manufacture its next twist.
He seems destined to become the show’s antihero, that morally questionable character who nevertheless inspires curiosity or identification from the audience. But for that to work, we need to understand his choices. Ambiguity can be an effective dramatic device; a lack of motivation is not necessarily one.
Can One Letter Resolve Eight Episodes of War?
The final episode, titled Partners, concentrates some of the season’s most convenient narrative developments. Johnny retrieves a letter from Morgan that Smallwood had intercepted and torn up. In it, the businessman expressed a willingness to offer Carla a generous division of his assets, including consideration for the wealth he might accumulate in the future.
The document completely changes the perspective of the conflict. Suddenly, Morgan appears far less interested in financially destroying his wife than the lawyers had led everyone to believe. Carla discovers that she may have been fighting against a version of her husband constructed by the very professionals hired to represent them.
It is an interesting idea, but the solution feels far too easy. A letter that should have been discarded remains conveniently available to be recovered at the precise moment Johnny needs to save his career. And its contents somehow carry enough weight to dismantle a dispute involving betrayals, public humiliation, mistrust, and a prolonged legal battle.
The issue is not whether an agreement was possible. On the contrary, it would be entirely plausible for two people with a shared history to abandon their legal battle and negotiate directly. The problem is that War never built the emotional foundation for that possibility. What should represent a profound shift in how Carla and Morgan perceive each other happens almost overnight.
There is also the revelation involving Gillian and the leak concerning Flora, which adds yet another layer of hidden agendas to the story. Once again, people close to the couple appear to be exploiting the separation for their own benefit. However, the series accumulates so many manipulations that some revelations lose their impact before their consequences can be properly explored.
In the end, Carla secures a stake in Zephyr, financial guarantees, and a shared-custody arrangement. The legal battle ends without the judge having to determine its outcome. And the couple reappears with their son in Normandy, in a conclusion that suggests a serenity almost incompatible with everything we have just watched.
Nick and Serena: The Marriage That Could Have Explained Everything
Curiously, perhaps the most interesting relationship in War is not Carla and Morgan’s but that of the lawyers themselves, Nick Taylor (James McArdle) and Serena Byrne (Phoebe Fox).
Married, business partners, and about to become parents, the two live in a relationship where work, ambition, power, and intimacy are permanently intertwined. The dispute between Carla and Morgan exposes tensions within the firm, differences in strategy, and resentments that extend beyond the professional environment. Serena wants recognition, particularly from Beatrice, while Nick responds to his wife’s insecurity with an aggressiveness that reveals problems dating back long before the trial.
Interestingly, both work professionally with the dissolution of relationships while struggling to manage their own marriage. They understand the mechanisms of separation, know how words and gestures can be weaponized against someone, and are fully aware of the consequences of turning intimate disagreements into power struggles. Yet they reproduce at home the same behaviors they exploit in court.
The series therefore had two marriages at different stages of deterioration. On one side, Carla and Morgan, engaged in a multimillion-dollar divorce. On the other, Nick and Serena, trying to preserve a relationship complicated by professional interests, competition, and resentment. It was an opportunity to show how the need to win can replace the ability to listen, both in marriage and at work.
But once again, War chooses to interrupt the development of the conflict with another twist. Serena goes into labor just as Johnny returns asking for another opportunity. The baby’s arrival temporarily suspends the couple’s differences and leaves for the second season questions that could have made the first much more compelling.

The True Meaning of Partners
The title of the final episode may reveal George Kay’s most intelligent intention. Partners can refer to business partners, colleagues in a law firm, or two people sharing a marriage. All these relationships require trust, negotiation, and recognition of interests that do not always align.
Carla and Morgan seem to recover some form of partnership when they stop allowing their lawyers to determine the course of their lives. Nick and Serena, by contrast, end the season confronting the weaknesses of their personal and professional union. Johnny, who spent eight episodes trying to earn a place among those he admires, discovers that belonging to a group requires something his ambition repeatedly compromises: trust.
There is thematic coherence in this conclusion. The problem lies in its execution. The series seems determined to demonstrate that the lawyers, rather than the couple, were the true architects of the war. But by concentrating almost entirely on the firms’ strategies, it failed to sufficiently develop the people who were supposed to suffer the consequences of those strategies.
The second season, planned from the beginning, will feature another legal case, this time involving defamation. It may also clarify the questions left unanswered about Johnny, Nick, and Serena. But the prospect of future episodes does not erase the weaknesses of the current season’s conclusion.
War has an excellent cast, sophisticated production values, and a premise capable of sustaining a far more complex drama. Its twists keep viewers interested, but they do not always withstand closer examination of the characters’ motivations. And the finale, despite its relevant irony, ultimately exposes the season’s central problem: after working so hard to show us how a war is manufactured, the series seems to forget that it needed to convince us there was a marriage worth fighting for.
Perhaps that is the real revelation: Carla and Morgan were never the true protagonists of War. They were the battlefield for professionals more interested in defeating one another than in solving their clients’ problems.
It is a potentially powerful criticism of the way family law can operate. But it would have been far more effective if the series had devoted as much attention to what happens to people when love ends and conflict begins as it did to the dirty tricks employed by their lawyers.
Descubra mais sobre
Assine para receber nossas notícias mais recentes por e-mail.
